Plot or Prose?

[Chris Tusa]

I saw this question on another forum, and I'm really interested in finding out what all of you think. So here goes: when you read, are you looking for a good plot or good prose? Will you keep reading a book that contains no obvious plot if it contains fresh and unique writing? Let me know what you think.

[William Butler]

A story that is written well but has a plot that is as dry as dirt, is still a story that's as dry as dirt. I think both elements are needed in order for a story to be worth my while. Otherwise I may as well be reading a well written dictionary, technical manual, or trade publication.

[Robin Layne]

I read for both plot and prose; both are important to me. Frankly, I don't think I've ever read a piece of fiction that contains no plot. I don't imagine it would appeal to me. I do, however, read poetry and it doesn't necessarily have a "plot." Why do you ask? Are you thinking of writing something without a plot? I suppose some literary fiction doesn't have one.

[Rebecca J Vickery]

With me it is definitely plot unless I'm reading poetry or a techie article. I read for enjoyment and escape from the worries of the moment. So I need a well-developed plot and good character development to keep me turning the pages. Otherwise I'll throw it down and pick up another. I'm not going to force myself to slog through a book just to say I read it. Too many great reads waiting to be read to do that.

[Jeanette Davis]

When I read a book, I want to be thoroughly absorbed in the plot. It has to be a good plot that I can't figure out before I am mid-book like most books I've read. Grammatical errors are distractions and annoy me. The most prolific examples of excellent writing that is composed of plot and prose are Taylor Caldwell's and Ayn Rand's books. They were masters of both. Oh, and their english was excellent.

[Lex Bumm]

Chris,
I am looking for both, although I will finish a book not really well written, but with a great plot. A well written book with an interesting plot I will finiish and recommend to others.
Lex

[win blevins]

Short thoughts: I'm a novelist and an acquiriing editor and don't focus much on plot in either role. Story, that's what matters to me. Someone said that plot is where the author wants to go, and story is where the characters want to go. That's not a bad definition. In story, characters lead the way and the tale grows organically. Any book by Robert B. Parker, in my opinion, is a good example.

Although prose style is a fine thing, it never comes first with me. When I see a book that puts it first, I consider that a literary novel, which I seldom read and never acquire. I don't want the reader's attention diverted by, "Wow, what a phrase." I want him to stay in the story, absorbed in its (apparent) reality.

So neither plot nor style. Characters and story

win blevins
www.winblevins.com